Introduction
The cryptocurrency market has seen significant growth in recent years, with more people diving into crypto trading. However, with the increasing interest comes the rise of misleading data, particularly fake trading volumes. Fake trading volumes can mislead traders, making them think there's a lot of market activity when, in reality, there isn’t. This not only affects the market’s integrity but also creates an environment where traders may make poor decisions. So, how can you tell when trading volumes are fake? In this blog, we’ll explore the steps and methods you can use to identify fake trading volumes on crypto exchanges.
Understanding the Impact of Fake Trading Volumes
Fake trading volumes aren't just about inflated numbers; they can mislead traders into making decisions based on inaccurate information. They can create a false sense of liquidity and volatility, which can be especially dangerous for new traders who are just starting. A study by the Blockchain Transparency Institute in 2019 revealed that a large percentage of the reported trading volume on some exchanges was fake. In fact, a whopping 80% of the trading volume on some exchanges was artificially inflated by wash trading a method of manipulating the market where traders buy and sell assets to create the illusion of activity.
While it’s not possible to completely avoid trading volume manipulation, understanding how to identify fake volumes is crucial for making smart decisions.
Key Indicators of Fake Trading Volumes
Fake trading volumes can be tricky to spot, but there are certain red flags you can look out for. Here’s how to assess whether the trading volume reported by an exchange is genuine or not.
Look for Consistency in Trading Volume
A common tactic for inflating trading volume is to show erratic spikes in activity, especially if these spikes are short-lived. If you see a sudden surge in trading volume followed by a sharp decline, this could be an indication of artificial trading activity. In a healthy, active market, volume tends to be more consistent, with gradual fluctuations that align with real market sentiment and events.
Examine Price Movements in Relation to Volume
In real trading, volume typically increases when there’s a major price movement. However, when fake volumes are pumped, the price often remains stagnant or doesn’t move in proportion to the spike in trading volume. If you see large volumes with little to no price action, or price movements that seem out of sync with the volume, this is a sign of potential manipulation.
For example, let's consider the case of Bitfinex and Tether in 2017. The exchange was accused of artificially inflating the Bitcoin price by issuing USDT tokens to trade Bitcoin. The trade volumes on the exchange were much higher than those on other exchanges, creating the illusion of increased demand. Despite the high trading volumes, the price movement didn’t reflect the sudden surge in volume, which raised suspicions about the legitimacy of the trades.
Check for Wash Trading
Wash trading is one of the most common methods of fake volume generation. In wash trading, traders (or bots) buy and sell the same asset to create the illusion of high trading activity. The trades don’t involve actual market risk since the same person is on both sides of the trade. This creates a misleading appearance of liquidity.
To spot wash trading, check the order books of the exchange. If there’s a lot of activity in the order book, but little to no market depth (meaning there aren’t real buyers or sellers willing to make a deal), this is a strong sign of manipulation. Wash trading often leads to large orders being placed but never actually filled, which creates the illusion of higher volume.
Monitor Market Depth
Market depth is an important indicator of liquidity. In healthy markets, there are typically a large number of buy and sell orders at different price levels. In manipulated markets, you’ll often notice shallow order books with only a few buy or sell orders at certain price levels. This lack of depth may indicate that the volume is artificially inflated, as real traders aren’t willing to engage at these levels.
For instance, on some exchanges where fake volumes are prevalent, the market depth might seem unusually shallow compared to other exchanges with similar assets. This can be a major clue that the trading activity is not as robust as the volume numbers suggest.
Verify With Third-Party Data Sources
If you want to confirm the authenticity of the trading volume data, consider checking third-party platforms that track trading volumes across multiple exchanges. Websites like CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko aggregate volume data from a wide range of exchanges and can offer insights into whether the reported volume on a specific exchange seems out of line with others.
In some cases, exchanges might report high trading volumes without disclosing whether the volume is real or inflated through methods like wash trading. Cross-referencing volume data across several sources can help you spot discrepancies and determine if a particular exchange is inflating their numbers.
Examine Exchange Reputation and History
Some exchanges have built a reputation for listing questionable assets or engaging in practices that don’t align with industry standards. If you’re trading on a lesser-known exchange or one with a history of dubious activity, be extra cautious with trading volume data.
For example, in 2018, the cryptocurrency exchange Bitgrail was accused of inflating the trading volumes for certain coins. This led to a significant loss for investors who relied on these volumes to make trading decisions. If an exchange has a shady track record or operates in a jurisdiction with weak regulation, it may be more prone to manipulating trading volumes.
Stay Aware of Trading Bots
While not necessarily a form of manipulation, trading bots can sometimes create the illusion of higher volumes, especially in less liquid markets. Bots can execute a large number of trades in a short period, which may make it appear as though there’s more activity than there actually is. By analyzing the trading patterns and frequency of transactions, you can often identify bot-driven volume.
In 2020, the exchange Binance was scrutinized for allowing trading bots to artificially inflate the volumes of specific assets. Although bots themselves aren’t inherently bad, their activity can distort the perception of a market’s real liquidity.
Use Volume-Weighted Average Price (VWAP)
VWAP is a trading indicator used to assess the price at which an asset has traded throughout the day, weighted by volume. By comparing the VWAP to the actual price, you can identify discrepancies between the volume-weighted price and the current price. If the VWAP shows a significant difference from the current price despite a high volume, there could be manipulation at play.
This technique is commonly used by institutional traders to identify trends and potential manipulations in the market. By analyzing the VWAP, you can avoid falling for artificially inflated volumes and instead focus on real price movements.
Conclusion
Identifying fake trading volumes is essential to making informed decisions in the crypto market. While it can be challenging, knowing the key indicators and understanding how exchanges might manipulate data can give you an edge. By staying vigilant and relying on third-party data, market depth analysis, and reputable exchanges, you can protect yourself from misleading volume data and avoid potential losses. Remember, the crypto market is still young and evolving, and staying informed will help you make better decisions as the landscape continues to change.
FAQs
What is wash trading in crypto?
Wash trading occurs when a trader buys and sells the same asset to create the illusion of high market activity. This doesn’t involve any real market risk since the trader is on both sides of the transaction.
How do I check the authenticity of trading volume on an exchange?
You can check the authenticity of trading volumes by cross-referencing data from multiple third-party platforms like CoinMarketCap and CoinGecko. Additionally, monitoring the price movements in relation to volume and checking for consistency can help you spot fake volumes.
Why do exchanges inflate trading volumes?
Exchanges may inflate trading volumes to attract more traders or to appear more liquid. This can create a false sense of market activity, which can influence the decisions of new or uninformed traders.
Can trading bots manipulate volumes?
Yes, trading bots can artificially inflate trading volumes, especially in less liquid markets. By executing a high number of trades in a short period, bots can make the market appear more active than it actually is.
0 Comments